BoomFrog wrote:FoS: Angua for making an in game issue about what has been stated as an out of game problem.
On the other hand, I would prefer RR to either ask for a replacement or actively participate.
lolwut. If someone is not posting, that is an in game issue. Not posting is anti-town behaviour.
They may have very good reasons for not posting (clearly nobody expects a game of mafia to take precedence over, ya know, life), but if they are continuously unable to post enough to play properly, they should not be in the game. A decision to stay in the game without contributing is hurting town.
You seem to acknowledge this in the second line I quoted, which makes me very confused what that FoS is about.
(I realize that RoadieRich has since posted - my comment is about BoomFrog's argument, not about RR.)
webby wrote:I can't see anything that would explain why Entropy would suddenly decide to make the statement he did - especially as he didn't have any abilities.
It's possible that he wanted everyone to think he was a lyncher, because once uncovered, they don't pose much of a threat to town. Much like convincing people you're a jester, convincing them you're a lyncher doesn't really give them incentive to lynch you. Would've been poorly executed, though.
Alternatively, one of his teammates has a relevant ability and they coordinated things.
BoomFrog wrote:Obviously I agree that moving the lynch away was reasonable at the time, but its the way infina tried to do it that is scummy. He tried to get it back on GL and with very very poor reasoning.
I used a valid reasoning, maybe not worded in the best of ways. But we have other, bigger fish to fry. Does anyone have any results that leads us to a member of Harry's gang for today's lynch?There are two each that should be left in Eddy's, Rory's and Dog's gangs, and a full four in Harry's. That is our biggest concern right now.
Wow, that is some exemplary "I'm not scummy OH GUYS LOOK OVER THERE AT THOSE OTHER SCUMMY THINGS QUCIKLY" you've got going on there. (Damn, upon reading further this has been pointed out by RR already. Well, he's right.)
BoomFrog wrote:GL since you've claimed, could you claim some more info that would not hurt your team but would help prove your claim down the road. Such as, what are the character names of all the members of your gang? Is Winston in both Rory's and Winston's gang? Are all the members of your gang survivors?
+ How many members are there?
(I'll understand if you don't want to answer ALL THE QUESTIONS, but BoomFrog's point is a good one: is there any info you can share relatively safely?)