I am frankly astounded that anyone is buying cemper's 'townslip' over the night chat.
How the hell would scum choose the nightkill if there's no night chat and there's a last minute bandwagon??? You know, like what happened. Sure, you could require them to put in a bunch of conditionals for who gets targeted, but then you may as well make the game nightless. And it's not terribly newbie friendly.
I'm also surprised that people are giving Hari townie credit for being on the PW lynch despite Hari explicitly saying they were voting for PW in hope for a NL! Trying to force a NL when the consensus is that a lynch should go through is ridiculously antitown.
If I've read the spoilers correctly, Sabrar is our watcher and BoomFrog is the doctor, but they're not the ones drawing the most suspicion right now, so this is looking kinda bad unless the flip tomorrow gets people on the right path. What will be interesting is who scum NKs, as anyone they kill should reduce their hiding spots a bunch. Hey, maybe BoomFrog can buy another lynch with a successful protect?
Pro tip: if someone pushes for NL with either no justification or an extremely flimsy one (at least Sabrar and Laserguy tried defending the position),
they're pretty likely to be scum. Or, apparently, Madge. I was actually betting she was either scum or a selfish PR who gets info, so finding out she was vanilla... Have to take that into account for future games. Less of an issue in closed games anyway, as with no idea how many kills or powers are going around, NL is just atrocious.
For the record, if the Doctor was guaranteed ineffective in this setup, then NL D1 is fine. But only then, and you should debate over it a bunch beforehand to have more stuff to talk about D2. So no autolynches in future games if I do propose NL D1 plz

(if it's an open setup. Closed, go nuts)
That ended up long, but I kind of want to whack some people over the head for what they're not looking at. Probably being really biased too from my cushy spoilered position but aaarggg come on go for the NLers there's both scum in there!