xkcd

LaserGuy

Vicarin wrote:Here, I'll take out the irrelevant bits.

I like that you took out the parts that actually show that you believe Zen's claim as "irrelevant".

LaserGuy

Out of those games, I'm pretty sure all but X-Men had an SK (as you say, X-Men was kind of weird, and also high powered). Going by the single observed kill and likelihood of a cult, along with town probably having weaker powers to offset the multilynch, I'd put the chance of multiple protective rol...

LaserGuy

Reads: bessie: For once I've found myself on the same page as bessie a lot this game. I think her progressions on Vic/heury have been very natural and well thought out, and I don't really get any pings from her to speak of. Very likely Town, especially if heury ends up flipping scum. EGW: Has been l...

LaserGuy

LaserGuy wrote:@Vic: Does your role explicitly only protect against kills?

Actually, let's be specific: Does your role suggest that it protects from recruiting actions?

LaserGuy

@Vic: Does your role explicitly only protect against kills?

LaserGuy

You could run the game dayless. Make a couple chat groups, give some interesting night actions and a few messaging powers. Threads are very short that way

LaserGuy

Vote: EGW

LaserGuy

Someone's going to have to explain how a lyncher bodyguard could work because that role sounds hilarious. Well, the fact that you obviously don't understand what I'm suggesting means you probably don't have a safeclaim :roll: Unvote This is the theory: Okay, you're scum, or lyncher, or whatever...

LaserGuy

Do you have any particular kind of indie that you think I am Laserguy? I think you're probably some sort of lyncher/assassin type role. I thought that was pretty obvious from the comments leading up to your wagon. If you think that I have a Bodyguard safe claim, then that'd be pretty hard for me to...

LaserGuy

@wam any explanation of what your theory is then? I knew marines had been mentioned even if i didnt clock it was you and were in the game. Bodyguard would not make sense for any other role. This argument only makes sense if scum has no safe claims. So your saying that scum vics safe claim.lines up ...

LaserGuy

wam wrote:Actually just occurred to me. Madge can you claim your role?

And, yes, it is a bit weird that you're trying to clear Vicarin using the same argument that was made to vote him up in he first place

LaserGuy

wam wrote:
Vicarin wrote:@wam any explanation of what your theory is then?

I knew marines had been mentioned even if i didnt clock it was you and were in the game. Bodyguard would not make sense for any other role.

This argument only makes sense if scum has no safe claims.

LaserGuy

Thanks Vic. I actually would use my bodyguard. Like I said I think roles are meant to be used. Sabrar I haven't read your post yet, still at work. Vic, Zen, George is fine with me. What, why? What changed. Additionally, you really think scum!zen pressured people into lynching bud!heury? Or for that...

LaserGuy

Why didn't you bodyguard PW? He was the obvious NK target.

LaserGuy

Hmm... I think I have a good idea of what role plytho is softing, and his likely result.

LaserGuy

This is such a weird game.

@wam: What results do you get for mafia/indie?

Vic, Zen, George is fine with me.

LaserGuy

Russian leader Vladimir Putin has just announced that Russia has produced a new line of nuclear weapons specifically designed to counter ballistic missile defense systems. [Putin] noted that Russia had to develop the new weapons as the U.S. has developed a missile defence system that threatened to u...

LaserGuy

That's not an answer. Why does Town!Zen imply scum!wam? What's the connection you're drawing here? Somewhere along the line when I reread the thread I got the impression that if Zen is town then wam would be the most likely to attack him while knowing he can't be scum. I hope you'll appreciate that...

LaserGuy

Already answered here.

LaserGuy

Watching all this speculation about why I want the role names is kinda weird. I think role names may be useful because scum may not have false claims or have bad ones. The main flaw with this (which I am astounded that no-one has said) is that I suspect scum will have infiltrated the command struct...

LaserGuy

Sabrar wrote:I find that unlikely. Could happen of course. Could be scum!LaserGuy defending his buddy. Not sure of anything.

That's not an answer. Why does Town!Zen imply scum!wam? What's the connection you're drawing here?

LaserGuy

Why can't both be Town?

LaserGuy

LaserGuy wrote:I would advise against claiming your rank

And if your rank can be deduced from your role, you might want to hold off until after we lynch Vic.

LaserGuy

I would advise against claiming your rank

LaserGuy

Vicarin on player names (sorry, I know you've caught most of this already bessie, just putting it in one place): About the h_a lynch: it possibly was ill-advised to do so in a rush without further claim info (for goodness sake claim your rank too) , but I was frantic to get at least one lynch throug...

LaserGuy

I'm just trying to get more of a grip on the setup seeing as we've only had 1 actual flip so far. D3 should hopefully be very enlightening. Nope. You’re blatantly and aggressively fishing for what should be a fairly inconsequential piece of flavor information. But you want it pretty badly. Perhaps ...

LaserGuy

Assorted questions on reread: @Vic: Beyond giving town worse versions of normal roles (single or two shot cop instead of cop for example), or giving mafia a bunch of roleblocks/strongmen/ cops to work with, I'm not sure what the best way of balancing this sort of game would be. What do y...

LaserGuy

Apparently having someone completely unqualified and inexperienced, in some financial difficulty and with conflicts of interests all over the world in a position of importance within the government has not gone unnoticed by other countries. And no, I'm not referring to Trump in this instance. Offici...

LaserGuy

I'm actually not voting ATM.

I would really strongly prefer that nobody hammers until Zen at least gets back to explain himself. We have lots of time on the clock.

LaserGuy

@laser. Why sheep at that point? I was assuming the mod was going to end the day at any point and wanted at least one non-Zen lynch before the day was over. I don't have a strong read on you one way or the other, so I was willing to go along and try to build momentum on something. As a mod.in a clo...

LaserGuy

Executive Order: Lights Out That was pretty funny :lol: I'm assuming you have some reads you'd like to share with us now? @Sabrar, if heuy was a cop, his result would have been of the form UNE/something else. He wouldn't have a result of Town. And he probably wouldn't have had cop as his rolename. ...

LaserGuy

Sabrar wrote:
Sabrar wrote:One sentence. Scum!heury had no reason to claim.
I still think this has more weight than any other reason combined.

@Sabrar, if heuy was a cop, his result would have been of the form UNE/something else. He wouldn't have a result of Town. And he probably wouldn't have had cop as his rolename.

LaserGuy

I think we're short votes for anything more tonight. I'll move to wam in the morning if you need the extra vote and thread is still open.

Vote: freezeblade

LaserGuy

Stellaris

Spoiler:

LaserGuy

Glad I was awake for this

LaserGuy

Zenii wrote:Executive Order: Lights Out

Because of this

LaserGuy

Hammer please.

LaserGuy

@Vic: I don't think Zen's power can co-exist with a cult. If he were culted, game would be over immediately since they could just end the day arbitrarily.

LaserGuy

So that's very interesting.

LaserGuy

@Sabrar: I agree that he has no reason to claim, but that claim makes no sense whatsoever. Why would he cop a townread? And not, I dunno, Zen?

Search found 5669 matches